top of page

Revelation Hiding in Plain Sight

2 days ago
4 min read

Sandwiched between the parable of the sower and its explanation, Matthew narrates a key moment between Jesus and his disciples. Later on and alone with Jesus, the disciples ask him why he speaks in parables. Jesus’ response turns on his citation of Isa 6:9-10. Due to the importance of this citation, this reflection is devoted to a look at that text and its relation to Jesus’ use of parables.

Beginning with the context of the citation, there are parallels between Isaiah’s commissioning vision and the visions of the heavenly counsel that Amos (Amos 9:1) and Micaiah (1 Kgs 22:19) report elsewhere. In each case, “the volunteer is to blind the hearer to the truth. In the case of 1 Kings, Ahab is to be deceived into going into battle (1 Kgs 22:20), while in Isaiah, the prophet is to dull his hearers (Isa 6:9-10), particularly King Ahaz (as seen in Isaiah 7).”[1] Importantly, though, both Micaiah and Isaiah reveal their commission to blind. After all, Micaiah explicitly tells Ahab that a lying spirit has been sent into his false prophets (1 Kgs 22:21-21). Objectively speaking, then, Ahab was given all that he needed to repent of his folly, but subjectively he was both too hardened in himself and too hardened by God’s judgment to encounter Micaiah’s words as an invitation to repentance. It is as though God’s revelation through Micaiah was hiding in plain sight. Analogously, if Isaiah ever described his theophanic encounter before he inscribed it, something similar would have been the case for his audience. Objectively, Isaiah’s hearers would have what they needed to repent of their hardness of heart.

Subjectively, however, Isa 6:9-10 indicates that God’s revelation will remain hiding in plain sight. The grammar of these verses “means that it is God’s intention to render his people obdurate through the proclamation of his prophet. The purpose of this obduracy, it would appear, is either to render judgment certain, as is implied in vv11-13, or perhaps to make it more fully deserved. It is possible that both ideas are in view.”[2] E.J. Young adds the nuance that these words to Isaiah carry with them a “certain amount of irony. ‘Hear,’ we may envision the prophet crying, ‘but of course you will not hear.’”[3] It is not the words themselves but the response to these words by those who encounter them that will differentiate between penitence or perishing.[4] That ties Isa 6:9-10 to the parable of the sower, especially as that parable explains why the true family of God are those who both hear and do God’s word.

Moreover, it was precisely Isaiah’s proclamation, rather than a lack of it, that produced its effect: “It was not darkness and a famine of hearing the word of God that would destroy the nation; it was light, too much light. It was this very light which would blind the people.”[5] And yet, that did not mean that Isaiah’s method was a part of the hardening effect, as though “obscurity of expression or complexity of message” was required in order to bring about the hardening.[6] Objectively considered, the message was clear, and the content was familiar enough to the audience to leave them without excuse. Subjectively, it was hiding in plain sight because the people did not have the capacity to understand it. More than eyes and ears were required to apprehend God’s revelation, which is a foundational idea illustrated by the parable of the sower.

Finally, the prophetic language and intent of Isa 6:9-10 never categorically excluded the possibility of someone hearing and turning, for “even the harsh message of Isaiah seeks hearers and gains disciples (Isa 8:16-18).”[7] Even in its original setting, Isa 6:9-10 did not communicate an exclusively heart-hardening idea; the result of the encounter with Isaiah’s prophetic ministry involved, at least to some degree, the one being encountered by it, and the one being encountered by it required the enlightening work of the Holy Spirit to be able to discern that revelation which otherwise was hiding in plain sight. While the categories of insiders and outsiders were in flux during the ministry of Jesus, his promise of the Holy Spirit offers the definitive solution to the matter of revelation hiding in plain sight. The Spirit will lead God’s people into God’s truth.


[1] Craig A. Evans, To See and Not Perceive: Isaiah 6. 9-10 in Early Jewish and Christian Interpretation (Bloomsbury, 2009), 22.

[2] Evans, To See and Not Perceive, 19.

[3] Edward J. Young, The Book of Isaiah, 3 vols. (Eerdmans, 1972), 1:255.

[4] Thomas Jemielity argues that the Hebrew prophets, like satirists from Rome to the modern day, understood that their words alone will not effect moral change, and so the very language of prophecy and satire holds in tension the appeal to reform and the declaration of judgment. “Satire and prophecy thus seek and despair of reform at the same time, urge change yet expect none.” [Thomas Jemielity, Satire and the Hebrew Prophets, Literary Currents in Biblical Interpretation (Westminster John Knox Press, 1992), 79–83, esp. 81.]

[5] Young, Isaiah, 1:257.

[6] Motyer, The Prophecy of Isaiah, 79.

[7] Klyne Snodgrass, Stories with Intent: A Comprehensive Guide to the Parables of Jesus, 2nd ed. (Eerdmans, 2018), 160.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
Waterless Places

The old adage, “misery loves company,” may best describe unclean spirits, particularly as we learn about them in the Gospels. In the parable that Jesus gives in our text this morning, Matthew 12:43-45

 
 
The Unforgiveable Sin

In the course of the inevitable and escalating conflict between Jesus and his opponents, there comes a point when Jesus’ opponents begin to sling mud. They claim that he only casts out demons by demon

 
 
Sunday Practices

I am sometimes asked if this or that activity is acceptable to do on Sunday. Setting aside the endless arguments about whether Sunday is the Christian Sabbath or not, the substantial concern is whethe

 
 

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
SAY HELLO
SUNDAY SERVICES
OUR ADDRESS

Covenant Presbyterian Church

291 Parsonage Hill Road

Short Hills, New Jersey 07078

9:15 AM Sunday School (Sept-May)

10:30 AM Morning Worship

bottom of page